The Plainsman and the Lady

Bill Elliott

Sam Colton

Vera Ralston

Ann Arnesen

Gail Patrick

Cathy Arnesen

Joseph Schildkraut

Peter Marquette

Andy Clyde

Durango

Don 'Red' Barry

Feisty

Raymond Walburn

Judge Winters

Russell Hicks

Sen. Twin

William B. Davidson

Russell

Paul Hurst

Al

Charles Judels

Manuel Lopez

Byron Foulger

Simmons

Jack Lambert

Sival

Noble Johnson

Wassao

Grady Sutton

Secretary

Eva Puig

Anita Lopez

Chuck Roberson

Deputy (uncredited)