Holly by Nightfall

Eric Nelsen

Johnny

Jake Thomas

Caleb

Bryan Lillis

Eric

Jack Falahee

Graham

Hannah James

Holly

Will Brittain

Andrew

Hannah Kat Jones

Kate

Andriana Manfredi

Amy

Luxy Banner

Sarah

Thiago Palma

Oscar (as Thiago Palma)

Benjamin Rawls

Wynn

Lisa Mattheis

Wig Party

Demetrius Joseph

Club Bouncer

Margaret Phipps

Hannah

Camryn Adele Portagallo

Fairfax

Kia J. Williams

Bartender

Isabel Cooper

Barista